Three years ago a faint smudge of light called UHZ1 made headlines around the world. Seen as it was less than half a billion years after the Big Bang, the galaxy was said to host a black hole of 10 to 100 million solar masses, roughly matching the weight of all its stars combined. Such a monster so early seemed to back the idea that some black holes are born heavy, collapsing straight out of huge gas clouds. A new analysis now argues the evidence simply is not there.
Astronomers led by Fan Zou of the University of Michigan went back to the Chandra X-ray Observatory and combined every observation of the field, about 2.2 million seconds in total, including nearly a million seconds that had never been published. They added new mid-infrared images from the MIRI camera on the James Webb Space Telescope. Their paper appears in The Astrophysical Journal.
Everything hinged on a faint excess of hard X-ray photons in the first place. In the fuller dataset that surplus is only marginally significant, and its strength depends on exactly how the X-ray and Webb images are aligned. A genuine, steady source should also have grown clearer as exposure time piled up; instead the extra data added almost nothing. When the team tested many plausible alignments, just 0.1 percent of them produced a signal as strong as the one first reported.
Webb found no help either. A dust-shrouded black hole feeding vigorously should warm its surroundings and glow in the mid-infrared, yet UHZ1 stayed dark in all nine MIRI filters. That limits any hidden black hole to between ten and a thousand times fainter than the original interpretation required.
What remains looks like an ordinary young galaxy: low in mass, poor in heavy elements and busy forming stars, with around 100 million suns’ worth of them. The authors do not rule out a modest black hole, only an outsize one.
