A day after Donald Trump sat down with Vladimir Putin and Xi Jinping in Shenzhen, the debate over how to end the war in Ukraine moved to Berlin, and with it came a claim that, if it holds, could reshape the negotiations.

Jared Kushner, one of Washington’s special envoys, emerged from Thursday’s session of Kyiv’s European backers saying Moscow now seems “comfortable” with protection for Ukraine patterned on NATO’s mutual-defence clause, under which an assault on one ally is treated as an assault on every ally. He called it “a very important breakthrough”, while conceding that any deal would need monitoring and tough deterrence, and that it would have to serve American interests.

Nobody in Berlin treated the remark as settled. Moscow has not confirmed it publicly, and in Shenzhen Putin defended his core demands and promised a “painful” answer to Ukrainian strikes on the Kerch bridge.

Host Friedrich Merz used the gathering to send a message of his own. The German chancellor waved off the three-leader meeting in China as little more than staged pictures and warned that a “Yalta format” decided over the heads of Europeans would not bring peace. Future talks, he argued, must include Ukraine, Russia, the United States and Europe, with Germany, France, Britain, Poland and Italy speaking for the continent. He also promised strong backing for Kyiv in 2027, citing the €45 billion Brussels has reserved for that year.

Emmanuel Macron went further. Given what he sees as Moscow’s maximalist stance, the French president said Kyiv’s path into the alliance deserves a fresh debate, and he pressed partners to deliver missile interceptors without delay.

Volodymyr Zelenskyy, who attended in person, said Washington understood why Europe needed a seat at the table. He thanked partners but warned that Russian air raids keep intensifying and that Moscow has turned down every idea for de-escalation, which is why he wants the US to lean harder on the Kremlin.

Trump joined part of the meeting by telephone to brief participants on his Shenzhen talks.